Historic Resource Evaluations (HREs)
If you want to remodel, expand, alter the facade of, add an ADU to, or demolish an older building in San Francisco (typically 45 to 50 years old or older), the Planning Department often needs to know two things before approving permits: Does this building have special historic value? And if so, will your planned project harm the features that make it special? A Historic Resource Evaluation (HRE) is the independent architectural history report—prepared by a consultant meeting the Secretary of the Interior's Professional Qualification Standards—that answers those questions and results in the Planning Department's formal Historic Resource Review (HRR), though homeowners, architects, and planners often still call the entire process an 'HRE.'
Best suited for: Homeowners, property owners, architects, land-use attorneys, and housing developers navigating San Francisco Planning and Bay Area CEQA or SB 330 review.
When Do You Typically Need One?
- You are planning an exterior remodel, roof pop-up, horizontal addition, window replacement, ADU, or demolition on a San Francisco building constructed 45+ years ago.
- Your property is categorized as a 'Category B' (Unknown / Age-Eligible) or 'Category A' (Known Historic Resource) building on the San Francisco Property Information Map (PIM).
- San Francisco Planning has asked you to file a Historic Resource Review (HRR) application supported by consultant research—often referred to interchangeably as a 'Part I HRE' (significance evaluation) or 'Part II HRE' (project impact analysis)—or another California city requires California DPR 523 (523A / 523B) inventory forms.
- You are submitting a housing development under state streamlining statutes (such as SB 330, SB 9, or ministerial infill programs) and need rapid, defensible historic resource screening.
Understanding HREs and HRRs Without the Planning Jargon
San Francisco has one of the oldest housing and commercial building stocks on the West Coast. Because nearly two-thirds of the city’s buildings are at least half a century old, everyday construction permits routinely cross paths with historic preservation review under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA).
For most property owners, seeing historic review requirements on a Planning Department intake letter feels intimidating. In plain terms, the city lacks complete historical records for thousands of individual parcels—what San Francisco Planning calls Category B properties (buildings of sufficient age whose historical status hasn’t been formally decided yet). Independent research by a consultant meeting the Secretary of the Interior’s Professional Qualification Standards (36 CFR Part 61) fills in that blank objectively so planners have verified facts rather than guesswork.
HRE vs. HRR: Why You Will Hear Both Terms
If you talk to an architect, permit expediter, or city planner in San Francisco, you will hear HRE and HRR used almost interchangeably. Here is how they fit together:
- Historic Resource Evaluation (HRE): The in-depth historical research, architectural documentation, and project impact report prepared on your behalf by an independent historic preservation consultant.
- Historic Resource Review (HRR): The San Francisco Planning Department’s formal review application and determination that your HRE results in (sometimes still called an HRE—or historically an HRER—in everyday permitting conversations). Preservation staff review the consultant’s HRE findings to issue the city’s official determination on historic status and CEQA compliance.
The Two Core Questions Answered During Review
- Historical Significance & Integrity (Part I): Age alone does not make a building historic. Under California Register criteria, a property must be meaningfully tied to important historical events or patterns (Criterion 1), an important person (Criterion 2), distinctive architectural design or craftsmanship (Criterion 3), or archaeological/informational value (Criterion 4)—and it must still retain enough authentic physical features (its integrity) for someone looking at the building today to recognize that history.
- Project Compatibility (Part II): If the property is historically significant—individually or as a contributor to a historic district—Part II identifies its character-defining features (such as a Neo-Grec bay window, roofline cornice, wood siding, or entry portico) and evaluates whether your architect’s plans preserve those features under the Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for Rehabilitation so the project avoids a CEQA “substantial adverse change.”
California DPR 523 Forms, State Housing Laws (SB 330) & Bay Area Jurisdictions
Beyond San Francisco’s Planning Code, Reiter Preservation Consulting prepares California Department of Parks and Recreation (DPR 523A / 523B) forms and CEQA historic assessments across wider Bay Area jurisdictions—and advises architects, housing developers, and land-use counsel navigating SB 330 preliminary applications, SB 9, ADU additions, and Section 106 federal reviews where statutory timelines and objective historic determinations are critical.
What the Process Looks Like Step by Step
Records & Archival Research
We trace original building permits, Sanborn fire insurance maps, historic photographs, city directories, architect biographies, and prior CHRIS / municipal surveys to uncover how the building evolved.
Site Visit & Architectural Documentation
We photograph and record the building's current exterior, site setting, and relevant spaces—distinguishing original historic craftsmanship from later remodels.
Significance, Integrity & DPR 523 Evaluation (HRE)
We prepare the Historic Resource Evaluation (or California DPR 523A/523B forms) examining California Register / CEQA criteria and whether enough authentic physical fabric ('historic integrity') survives today.
Resulting Historic Resource Review (HRR) & Standards Analysis
Your completed HRE documentation is submitted for San Francisco Planning's Historic Resource Review (HRR)—sometimes also called an HRE—resulting in the city's official historic determination and Secretary of the Interior's Standards impact review.
Reiter Preservation Consulting's Approach
Historic Resource Evaluations (HREs) are occasionally required by the San Francisco Planning Department in order to establish whether or not a building is a historic resource under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and how any planned changes may impact a structure’s significance. An HRE provides a more thorough examination of a building’s context, its ownership and alteration history, and provides descriptions of the building’s exterior, interior, and site. The report often establishes how a structure fits in the context of similar resources (thematically or geographically), and determines how proposed changes will impact features that demonstrate or embody that structure’s significant history.
HREs are typical examples of historic preservation documentation and provide much of the same information used in getting a property listed on the National Register of Historic Places, on the California Register, or on local historic resource lists. Barrett Reiter’s experience professionally and academically has given her extensive experience in researching and writing this type of report. While preservation is often accused of trying to freeze time, Barrett’s work in areas of high political and economic pressure helps her navigate what is historically significant, while allowing the flexibility to create layers of change that make our city’s heritage so rich. Additionally, her close attention to detail, her passion for this city’s history, and her genuine interest in the narrative of every building she works on, will make her a strong advocate for your project.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between a Historic Resource Evaluation (HRE) and a Historic Resource Review (HRR)?
A Historic Resource Evaluation (HRE) is the research and impact report prepared by a qualified historic preservation consultant, which is submitted to San Francisco Planning and results in a Historic Resource Review (HRR)—the city's formal review process and determination of historic status and project impacts. Because SF Planning used the HRE name for decades before introducing the HRR application umbrella, architects, planners, and homeowners frequently still call both the consultant report and the resulting city review an 'HRE.'
Who is legally qualified to prepare an HRE, HRR report, or DPR 523 form?
San Francisco Planning and California lead agencies require HREs and DPR 523 evaluations to be prepared by a professional who meets the Secretary of the Interior's Professional Qualification Standards (36 CFR Part 61) in Architectural History or History. Principal Barrett Reiter holds an M.S. in Historic Preservation from Columbia University (GSAPP) and extensive public- and private-sector architectural history experience meeting these federal standards.
What are California DPR 523 forms, and when are they used instead of a narrative HRE?
DPR 523 forms—administered by the California Department of Parks and Recreation / Office of Historic Preservation—are California's standardized historic inventory forms, including the Primary Record (DPR 523A) and Building, Structure, and Object Record (DPR 523B). Many Bay Area cities outside San Francisco (such as Oakland, Berkeley, San Mateo, Marin, and Peninsula municipalities) as well as state agencies require HRE findings to be submitted directly on DPR 523 forms with a recommended California Historical Resource Status Code.
How do California housing laws like SB 330, SB 9, and ADU rules interact with HREs?
State housing laws such as SB 330 (the Housing Crisis Act), SB 9 duplex/lot-split rules, and state Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU) statutes establish strict review timelines and objective standards—and often hinge on whether a site contains a formally listed or eligible historic structure. Commissioning an early HRE / historic screening establishes clear facts prior to or alongside an SB 330 preliminary application so housing projects avoid late-stage surprises.
Does needing an HRE / HRR mean I cannot remodel my house?
Not at all. First, just because a building is more than 45 or 50 years old does not automatically make it a protected historic resource—many older buildings have been heavily altered over time or are common examples that do not meet CEQA thresholds. Second, even when a building IS a historic resource, thoughtful additions, seismic upgrades, ADUs, and interior modernizations happen across San Francisco every day as long as key character-defining features are respected.